WORM, Air-Gap & Evidence That Survives Ransomware
Backup Immutability ensures your backups cannot be altered or deleted for a defined retention—so you can recover with confidence after ransomware, insider mistakes, or cloud misconfig.
SolveForce implements WORM (Write-Once-Read-Many), air-gapped accounts, MFA Delete, and audit-grade evidence across clouds and on-prem, wired into Cloud Backup and DRaaS runbooks.
Part of our continuity stack: 💾 Cloud Backup → /cloud-backup • 🚨 DRaaS → /draas
Crypto & identity: 🔑 Key Mgmt/HSM → /key-management • 🔐 Encryption → /encryption • 🔑 IAM → /iam
Evidence & automation: 📊 SIEM/SOAR → /siem-soar
🎯 Outcomes (Why Immutability)
- Ransomware resilience — backups resist encrypt/delete attempts and survive account compromise.
- Proven recovery — immutable test-restore artifacts prove clean points and timing.
- Regulatory assurance — WORM retention and legal hold satisfy audit & litigation needs.
- Operational safety — “oops-delete” and rogue admin actions can’t destroy your last resort.
- Measurable posture — dashboards for object lock coverage, MFA Delete, and drift alerts.
🧭 Scope (What We Make Immutable)
- Objects — S3 Object Lock (Governance/Compliance), Azure Immutable Blob, GCS Bucket Lock.
- Snapshots & images — EBS/VM/DB snapshot policies with copy-to-air-gap accounts and retention locks.
- Backup vaults — vault lock / policy freeze (cloud & appliance).
- Metadata & logs — backup job logs, checksums, and evidence stored in immutable tiers.
- SaaS — M365/Workspace/SFDC immutable copies via provider APIs and versioning.
Immutability is storage-level protection. It complements—but does not replace—good Cloud Backup schedules and DR orchestration. → /cloud-backup • /draas
🧱 Building Blocks (Spelled Out)
- WORM retention — time-bound locks on objects/snapshots; optional legal hold.
- Versioning — object/file versioning plus deny-delete policies.
- Air-gap account — cross-account/subscription/project with deny-by-default and limited one-way writes.
- MFA Delete / Approvals — second factor + change tickets for retention or policy edits.
- Key custody — CMK/HSM KEKs; envelope encryption; dual-control for key ops. → /key-management
- Network isolation — VPC endpoints/private links; no public paths; strict IAM & SCP guardrails. → /iam
🚦 What Immutability Is / Is Not
- Is: Storage-level protection that prevents change or delete until retention ends.
- Is not: A backup by itself, nor a DR plan. You still need schedules, replication, and runbooks. → /cloud-backup • /draas
🧰 Reference Patterns
A) Cloud-Native WORM (Single Cloud)
- S3 Object Lock (Compliance) or Immutable Blob + Versioning; copy to air-gap account; MFA Delete; retention tags per tier.
B) Hybrid (On-Prem → Cloud WORM)
- Image/agent backups to object store with Object Lock; vault lock; cross-region copy; optional colo cache for fast restores. → /colocation
C) Database & Log Chains
- Daily full + log shipping to immutable bucket; point-in-time restore with clean-point verification and checksums.
D) Kubernetes-Aware
- etcd/PVC snapshots to immutable object storage; manifests/Helm bundles hashed; namespace or cluster restore drills. → /kubernetes
E) SaaS Immutability
- M365/Workspace/SFDC item-level immutable copies; version + legal hold; granular restore (mailbox/file/item/object).
🛡️ Attack Model → Mitigations
| Threat | Mitigation |
|---|---|
| Ransomware encrypts primaries | WORM + air-gap account; copy-on-write; no overwrite; integrity checks |
| Rogue admin / stolen keys | IAM least-privilege; MFA Delete; dual-control; SCP/Policies deny-delete |
| Cloud account breach | Air-gapped destination; one-way replication role; no backchannel |
| Retention tamper | Vault/object lock Compliance mode; policy freeze; change approvals |
| Silent corruption / drift | Checksums; periodic test-restores; clean-point catalog |
📐 SLO Guardrails (You Can Measure)
| KPI / Control | Target (Recommended) |
|---|---|
| Object Lock coverage | = 100% of protected sets |
| Air-gap copy freshness (p95) | ≤ 15–60 min from primary landing |
| MFA Delete enforcement | = 100% for retention/policy edits |
| Test-restore cadence | Tier-1: Monthly • Tier-2: Quarterly • Tier-3: Semiannual |
| Evidence completeness | = 100% (locks, versions, tests) |
| Drift alert → ticket | ≤ 5 min |
SLO breaches open tickets and trigger SOAR playbooks (re-lock, re-copy, escalate). → /siem-soar
🔐 Security & Governance
- Keys — CMK/HSM KEKs; envelope encryption; dual-control & quorum for disable/destroy. → /key-management
- Identity — SSO/MFA; scoped roles; no long-lived access keys; break-glass with short TTL + recording. → /iam • /pam
- Network — private endpoints; egress restricted; origin cloaking; deny public object ACLs.
- Evidence — CloudTrail/Activity/Audit logs, lock states, retention changes, test artifacts shipped to SIEM; automated actions via SOAR. → /siem-soar
🚨 Ransomware Playbook (Clean-Point First)
1) Freeze retention clocks; copy latest to air-gap if behind.
2) Identify clean point from job logs & checksums; mark candidate restore sets.
3) Isolate infected networks; rotate creds/keys; step-up MFA for restores.
4) Restore to isolated recovery network; scan images; verify application probes.
5) Cutover with staged DNS/WAF/fencing; keep immutable originals until RCA closes.
→ Backups & DR orchestration: /cloud-backup • /draas
📊 Observability & Evidence
- Dashboards — object-lock coverage, air-gap freshness, job success %, clean-point catalog, test-restore timings.
- Artifacts — lock configs (JSON), policy hashes, job logs, checksums, screenshots, time-to-first-byte.
- SIEM — immutable logs (WORM/retention), change events, SOAR actions; monthly executive reports. → /siem-soar
💵 Cost Controls
- Lifecycle — hot → nearline → archive (Glacier/Deep Archive) with restore SLAs documented.
- Dedupe & compression — minimize stored TB and egress.
- Granular restores — restore only necessary objects/files to reduce retrieval costs.
- Cross-account egress planning — private endpoints; avoid public data paths.
🛠️ Implementation Blueprint (No-Surprise Rollout)
1) Classify datasets — tiers, owners, RPO/RTO; required retention & legal hold.
2) Enable immutability — Object Lock/Immutable Blob/Bucket Lock; Compliance mode where mandated.
3) Air-gap — create deny-by-default destination account/project; one-way replication role; no trust back.
4) IAM & approvals — SSO/MFA; SCPs; dual-control; ticketed change windows for locks/retention.
5) Key posture — CMK/HSM hierarchy; rotation; audit exports.
6) Network — private endpoints; egress restrict; monitoring.
7) Test-restore matrix — per tier/app; store artifacts; track clean-point catalog.
8) Dashboards & SIEM — coverage, freshness, drift; SOAR runbooks for lock drift, revoke, re-copy.
9) Drills — ransomware, accidental delete, region outage; publish RCAs & improvements.
✅ Pre-Engagement Checklist
- 📦 Dataset inventory (tier, owner, retention/holds, compliance tags).
- 🔐 Keys & IAM (CMK/HSM, MFA Delete, role scopes, break-glass).
- 🛰️ Air-gap account/project design & replication roles.
- 🌐 Private endpoints; deny public access; network policy.
- 🧪 Test-restore schedule, clean-point criteria, evidence format.
- 📊 SLO dashboards & alerting; SIEM/SOAR integration.
- 💰 Lifecycle & retrieval budgets; archive class choices.
🔄 Where Backup Immutability Fits (Recursive View)
1) Grammar — protected copies traverse Connectivity & Networks & Data Centers.
2) Syntax — lives in Cloud storage & backup flows.
3) Semantics — Cybersecurity + immutability preserve the truth of data.
4) Pragmatics — SolveForce AI flags drift, predicts risk windows, and suggests clean points.
5) Foundation — consistent terms via Primacy of Language.
6) Map — indexed in the SolveForce Codex & Knowledge Hub.
📞 Lock Down Backups That Can’t Be Encrypted or Deleted
Related pages:
Cloud Backup • DRaaS • Key Management / HSM • Encryption • IAM / SSO / MFA • SIEM / SOAR • Cybersecurity • Cloud • Networks & Data Centers • Knowledge Hub